Long COVID Patients Warned of Damaging Exercise Programme

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on email

#MEAction UK is getting the message out – don’t exercise if you have post-exertional malaise. We’ve sent a press notice to the UK media ahead of the release of draft revised National Institute of Health and Care Excellence guidelines on ME/CFS on 10th November. We’re highlighting the links between “Long Covid” and ME. In particular, we want people at risk to know about the danger of exercise if they have post-exertional malaise. We’ve already had a great article in Scottish Sunday Express and we will be doing more in depth work with press contacts before we put out a statement about the draft guidelines.

Click below to read the Scottish Sunday Express article:

#MEAction UK Press Release

COVID-19 Patients are at Risk of Developing Myalgic Encephalomyelitis

Many of the symptoms that some sufferers are experiencing after initial COVID-19 infection are not new or mysterious, according to #MEAction UK. Scientific studies are clear that myalgic encephalomyelitis (ME) often results from a viral infection and there have been significant increases in the number of people with ME following previous epidemics.  

ME Being Triggered By A Viral Outbreak Is Not New 

Speaking for #MEAction UK, Sian Leary said “Scientific evidence from past viral outbreaks shows that a significant subset of people suffering ongoing symptoms after initial COVID-19 illness are likely to develop ME.” 

In July, #MEAction UK wrote to UK Health Secretary Matt Hancock asking him to take immediate action to request that an immediate warning be put out to health authorities regarding graded exercise therapy and the current ME/CFS guidelines – noting that it harms a majority of people with ME. Critically the Health Secretary was asked to ensure all government and NHS England advice on post-COVID treatment and rehabilitation addresses the fact that patients could develop ME and that graded exercise and activity harms this patient population.

In early May, Professor Chris Ponting, Chair of Medical Bioinformatics at University of Edinburgh.  explained that he would “expect that [of the] people who have COVID-19 symptoms quite severely… about 10% [would] have fatigue-like syndromes after 6 months, given current evidence.”  

Dr. Alain Moreau, Université de Montréal, concurred. “Coronavirus leading to more cases of ME will happen for sure, unfortunately.  (In) a previous study in which ~200 people who survived the ICU in a previous outbreak of a coronavirus infection (SARS), close to one third developed ME/CFS-like symptoms… there are some preliminary reports of the same from COVID-19….  The question is not ‘will this happen’ but how many will suffer?”

Sadly, these predictions are now being seen to play out. 

Dr. Anthony Fauci, Director of the US National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases and member of the White House Coronavirus Task Force, has emphasised in several interviews that people who are not recovering after contracting COVID-19 are showing symptoms “that are highly suggestive of myalgic encephalomyelitis and chronic fatigue syndrome,” including severe fatigue, cognitive problems, chills and sweats and sleep problems.

People with Post Exertional Malaise Should NOT be Encouraged to Exercise 

Long-COVID patients are already reporting ME-like symptoms including the hallmark symptom of ME, post-exertional malaise.   

Dr Amy Small, a GP in Lothian who became ill early on in the outbreak, commented, “Having always been a very active person prior to long COVID, running several times a week and doing other exercise, I have found it very difficult to come to terms with the post-exertional malaise I suffer now.  I have, however, learnt, both from the ME community and the long COVID community that GET is potentially very damaging. It’s not in my nature not to “push” myself but I’ve learnt that the key to recovery is through pacing. Pacing isn’t as straightforward as it would seem but I have gradually managed to pick up my activity levels slowly over the last few months with adequate pacing and rest.” 

Post-exertional malaise (PEM) is a cardinal symptom of ME, unique to the disease, where cognitive or physical overexertion can lead to a flare of symptoms and/or the appearance of new symptoms, typically presenting 12 to 48 hours after the triggering event. People with post-exertional malaise or who have been diagnosed with ME should NOT be recommended to undertake graded exercise, which can have very serious, long-term consequences for their health. 

NICE Continues to Recommend Graded Exercise for ME 

Unfortunately, the current treatment for ME recommended by the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) is Graded Exercise Therapy (GET), which thousands of people with ME have long reported causes a deterioration in their health after undertaking graded exercise, even at low levels and for short periods of time. A recent, large-scale survey found that 80% of people with ME found no benefit or were significantly worse after graded exercise regimens.  Research has shown that people with ME who were given a period of enforced rest from onset had the best prognosis.

Exercise protocols prescribed for myalgic encephalomyelitis (ME) were powerful enough for Cherry to ignore the physiological realities of her disease. Cherry is now 100 percent bedridden. When 16-year-old Cherry from North London began the treatment prescribed for her ME in 2013, she was able to walk to her local hospital’s Fatigue Clinic. Her consultant had fast-tracked Cherry to immediately begin sessions of GET, in which patients work to gradually increase their activity and exercise levels.

It quickly became clear that pushing herself to build her activity levels was worsening Cherry. After six months of trying to push herself, Cherry had to send her mother to her six-month review consultation as she had become too weak to leave her bed, and had increasing neurological symptoms such as severe, daily headaches.

“We embarked on it in good faith because the doctor had a very good manner.  The problem with the disease is that you can do massive damage to your body systems, but it often doesn’t show up until months later. In hindsight I believe that the hospital consultant should have told Cherry to take a year and rest and let her body heal” said Cherry’s mother, Rachel. 

Cherry’s deterioration after undergoing GET is a common experience in the ME community. An analysis of over 18,000 patient responses to surveys on management of ME symptoms over a five year period reported that 57% deteriorated following GET.

#MEAction UK is demanding that NICE removes Graded Exercise Therapy from the recommendations in the revised guidelines for ME/CFS, a draft of which will be published this November. We have been campaigning for this for many years. The Centers for Disease Control in the US has already removed its recommendation for GET and has stated that graded exercise may cause harm. 

“Now the high numbers of people suffering similar symptoms following initial COVID infection makes this a critical action,” said #MEAction UK’s Sian Leary.  “Although NICE has already issued a statement that GET may not be appropriate for people with post COVID illness, we are concerned that several of the new NHS England clinics for COVID rehabilitation are recommending graded exercise or its equivalent to patients.”

It is essential that UK governments, the medical profession and the NHS recognise the harm done by Graded Exercise Therapy to people with ME and the potential damage to thousands more people with long COVID.  ME Action UK strongly suggests that these agencies talk to and learn from the ME community to ensure no further harm is done.

See #MEAction’s campaign for people to Stop, Rest Pace.

Further Information

#MEAction UK is an organisation of patients, carers and allies fighting for recognition and research for ME.

Share on facebook
Facebook
Share on twitter
Twitter
Share on whatsapp
WhatsApp
Share on google
Google+
Share on email
Email

1 thought on “Long COVID Patients Warned of Damaging Exercise Programme”

  1. This is a fantastic article the likes of which I have waited three decades to see. Well done indeed to all involved in it. Just one cautionary note though. Having lived in England during the setting up of the specialist clinics for ME. I found that the notion of multidisciplinary clinics is a dangerous one as it allows the behavioural proponents in and then you are stuck with them. All we need in Scotland for Covid or ME is the same as any other illness, knowledgeable consultants and GPs who are then able to refer patients on to any other discipline needed.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest News

Important News from Jennifer Brea

Today we announce that #MEAction’s co-founder and executive director, Jennifer Brea, is going to be transitioning to a board position so she can take time to focus on her health after five intense years of ME and advocacy. This will not happen immediately- we will be working hard to find a new Executive Director first!

Read More »

Help keep our work going

We rely on donations from people like you to keep fighting for equality for people with ME.

Donate

Get actions alerts and news direct to your inbox

You can choose what you want to be kept up to date on.

Subscribe
Scroll to Top