Update on Thane’s civil commitment case

Editor’s note: This update is provided by Thane’s care team.

UPDATE: Friday, February 5 , 2021

Thane was released from the hospital today and is home!


UPDATE: Wednesday, February 3 , 2021

Thane’s lawyer shared with us that the evaluation went very well on Monday morning. Thane agreed to a “continuance for dismissal,” which means that he will be discharged on Friday, assuming all goes according to plan. The petition will be continued for 30 days, at which point the court will dismiss it entirely. 

The next step will be ensuring that Thane gets the medical care he needs to address his weight loss. We are working to establish a new care team, including a local GP who trained under a ME/CFS clinician and a ME/CFS specialist. 

Thane still has a tough couple of days ahead in the hospital, so please send lots of good juju his way. The hospital environment and the threat of civil commitment have placed immense stress on Thane. Through it all, he has shown tremendous grace and strength. 

Thank you for the outpouring of support for Thane. Everyone’s efforts have helped to put Thane on a better path to healing.

UPDATE: Monday, February 1, 2021

After a long week, there has finally been some progress in Thane’s civil commitment case! There was not much new information to share until Friday, when the court eventually served Thane the papers concerning the commitment proceedings. 

The commitment process involves a series of steps. Thane is currently on a district court hold while awaiting his civil commitment hearing. He was finally assigned a court-appointed lawyer who has extensive experience in this area of the law. He seems excellent and has made it clear that he is on Thane’s side. His team is working to educate him on ME/CFS and how being in a hospital setting is causing harm to Thane’s condition and placing him at greater risk. 

Thane’s team has explained to his lawyer that ME/CFS patients often experience medical gaslighting and are diagnosed with a somatic disorder. Lacking a diagnostic test places patients like Thane in peril. Ask any ME/CFS patient, and they will tell you that they look somewhat “normal” on paper when it comes to basic testing. Doctors often conclude there is nothing wrong and default to a psychiatric diagnosis. This is wrong and has to stop.

People with ME/CFS need specialized testing to uncover energy metabolism problems, autonomic dysfunction, immune abnormalities, gut dysbiosis, and endocrine dysfunction that conspires to make patients very ill. Concluding that a severely-ill patient is a psych case without doing the specialized testing needed is negligent at best.

Experts on ME/CFS worldwide are lending their support and helping to advise on Thane’s case. 

Next steps

This coming week will be a big one for Thane – please hold him in your thoughts. The commitment process involves a preliminary hearing, which occurs on 2/1/2021, and the commitment hearing will take place on Thursday, 2/4/2021. Thane’s team has worked diligently to assemble the information needed to fight back. 

It is important to remember that there is still a good chance that Thane will go home this week. The court could decide that he does not fit the requirement for commitment. Even if the court determines that Thane meets the criteria, he could still be sent home on a provisional discharge. He has the full weight of the ME/CFS community on his side, including clinicians, lawyers, medical advocates, friends, and supporters who have jumped in to raise the visibility of Thane’s case. We are hopeful that once the court has the correct medical information, it will side in Thane’s favor and send him home, where he can begin to heal from this traumatic situation.

The bigger picture

Thane’s case highlights the medical misinformation that still surrounds ME/CFS patients. It also exposes a paradox that severely ill patients face. The sicker a patient becomes, the less access to the medical care they receive. Very few specialists in the United States can treat patients with such a complex medical picture – traveling to see one would destroy a severely-ill patient, and very few GPs have the expertise to handle one. Thane’s case also exposes the intersection of very severe illness and civil commitment. Sadly, Thane is not alone in this fight. 

We will fight together, in solidarity, to help ensure that severely-ill patients get the care they need and avoid civil commitment. 

Thank you for your ongoing support of Thane. Together we will win this.

For more information on severe ME/CFS:

From Thane: https://twitter.com/thane_black/status/1352972003536482305?s=20

IOM/National Academy of Medicine Report – Guide for Clinicians (2015) This report is long, but there is a shorter clinician’s guide:  https://www.nap.edu/resource/19012/MECFScliniciansguide.pdf

For the full report:  

Beyond Myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome: redefining an illness  https://www.nap.edu/read/19012/chapter/1#ix 

Diagnosing and treating myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome (ME/CFS) – US ME/CFS Clinician Coalition (2020) 

A concise and current document that is easy to share: 

https://batemanhornecenter.org/wp-content/uploads/filebase/Diagnosing-and-Treating-MECFS Handout-V2.pdf 

Dialogues of a Neglected Illness (Dialogues for ME/CFS) film series on very severe ME/CFS, featuring Dr. Nigel  Speight. Please scroll down to find the video listed under severe/very severe ME. These are exquisitely-done videos that give a voice to the unique needs of patients suffering from very severe ME. https://www.dialogues-mecfs.co.uk/films/severeme/

Whitney Dafoe’s moving letter in support of Holger Klintenberg. Holger is a person like  Thane with very serve ME/CFS battling against involuntary commitment in Sweden.  https://www.facebook.com/whitneydafoe/posts/232536848284015 

The Puzzle Solver: A scientist’s desperate quest to save his son 

This book is about Ron Davis, Ph.D., and Jane Dafoe, Ph.D., and their son Whitney Dafoe. It provides an excellent overview of the history of ME/CFS and captures the experience of people with a very severe form of this disease.  https://www.amazon.com/Puzzle-Solver-Scientists-Desperate-Illness/dp/0316492507


This beautiful documentary highlights the struggle people with severe ME/CFS patients face while seeking a diagnosis and treatment.  https://www.unrest.film/


4 thoughts on “Update on Thane’s civil commitment case”

  1. Keeping Thane in my prayers and hoping that his original issue has been addressed amidst all of this. He is living the nightmare that all of us with ME/CFS have. May his experience shed some light on the inhumane medical travesty we all fear and prompt the Powers-That-Be to finally provide funding to find appropriate answers.

    We’ve got your back, Thane. (((HUGS)))

  2. Im with you thane. The excuse from general Drs is that this condition isnt in any medical journals….. which is very untrue. They have already been misinformed and believe what the believe despite latest medical research. The very recent findings are published in several medical journals. It takes about 13 yrs for that knowledge to spill over into common practice. Problem here seems that most Drs are not keeping up with the advances made in research which is the real problem and very unfortunate. They just assume they already know it all. We need hospitals to have a lesson on this and jayco may need to be notified before they get sued.

Comments are closed.

Latest News

Image is a sky blue rectangle, with an image of the #MEAction Maryland's logo that has the words Maryland State Chapter over an image of a lighthouse. On the righthand side if the image are the words, Join #MEAction's Marylans's #HelpMESenator Campaign in black font.

Join #MEAction Maryland’s #HelpMESenator Campaign

We are writing this article to share some exciting news! On Tuesday, September 26, ME advocates delivered copies of the book, The Puzzle Solver, by Tracie White with Ronald W. Davis, PhD, along with information about ME and Long Covid to Senators on the Hill. The books were donated by an individual living with severe ME/CFS in an effort to raise

Read More »
a collection of millionsmisisng pictures featuring people protesting over the years in red shirts and with protest signs. white dashses connect the photos. the words words "the Story of the #MillionsMissing" is in white font in the top lefthand corner with the #MEAction logo there. The words "Coming Soon" is handwriting font is in the top righthand corner.

“#MillionsMissing is our drumbeat”–Preview Party 9/24

RSVP TODAY: We are hosting a preview party for the new, virtual Home of the #MillionsMissing this Sunday, September 24th, at 12 pm PT/ 3 pm ET/ 8 pm BST! RSVP & Get Zoom Link Here We have always had to be creative in telling Our Story – the story of M.E. – to the world

Read More »

JNNP to publish edited rapid response by MEAction UK.

MEAction UK have been in communication with the BMJ and are delighted to announce that the Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery & Psychiatry (JNNP) are publishing an edited version of our rapid response to  ‘Anomalies in the review process and interpretation of the evidence in the NICE guideline for chronic fatigue syndrome and myalgic encephalomyelitis’. We

Read More »