Sense About Statistics says: PACE trial doomed by flaws

Dr Rebecca Goldin, blogging for Sense About Statistics, has said that flaws in the design of the PACE trial “were enough to doom its results from the start”.
Her 7,000-word post described the study’s design and the extensive changes to the planned analyses.
Dr Goldin, who is the Director of the organisation, writes, “The study is under increasing scrutiny by scientists and science writers about whether its conclusions are valid. The question of how all this happened and how the criticism is being handled have sent shockwaves through medicine”.
She added, “The results from PACE… have been published in prestigious journals and influenced public health recommendations around the world; and yet, unraveling this design and the characterization of the outcomes of the trial has left many people, including me, unsure this study has any scientific merit. How did the study go unchallenged for five years?”
Sense About Statistics is a collaboration between Sense About Science USA and the American Statistical Association. It is aimed particularly at journalists who need to understand statistics in order to accurately report the news. Dr Goldin’s analysis of the trial includes its media coverage as well as its design and statistical aspects.
She notes that “Patients pointed out flaws in the trial and asked for more data to analyze the claims, but their concerns were dismissed” until the appearance of Dr David Tuller’s analysis of the trial, which, she said, “described scientifically stunning problems”.
She reported that, now that 42 scientists have signed an open letter to The Lancet requesting independent re-analysis of the trial, the journal’s editor has invited the group to submit a letter about the concerns for publication.
Sense About Science’s director, Trevor Butterworth, accompanied the article with an editorial in which he described CFS as “a paralyzing syndrome that is as near to an off-switch on life as one can imagine”.
He wrote, “The reaction to patient criticism and Tuller’s story by the PACE researchers and the Lancet has been to deflect rather than to dissect… David Tuller may not get a Pulitzer Prize for investigating PACE trial on a blog; but his service to—and we do not exaggerate—millions of sufferers around the world make it hard for us to think of another work of journalism so deserving of commendation.”

Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp
Email

1 thought on “Sense About Statistics says: PACE trial doomed by flaws”

Comments are closed.

Latest News

A laptop sitting on a desk. In the background, you can see a cup and saucer, some post-it notes and a folder. On the screen is the Scottish Government's website, with a large title that says 'Scottish Good Practice Statement on Myalgic Encephalomyelitis / Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (ME-CFS).' A red banner is at the bottom of the photo with white writing which says, '#MEAction Scotland responds to the updated Scottish Good Practice Statement on ME.’ The ME Action Scotland logo is in the top left corner.

#MEAction Scotland responds to the updated Scottish Good Practice Statement

The Scottish Government published the updated Scottish Good Practice Statement (SGPS) on ME-CFS on 28th February 2023.  The decision to update the Scottish Good Practice Statement, originally published in 2010, was a result of the Scottish stakeholder review of the 2021 NICE guideline on ME/CFS, and its recommendations for implementing the guideline in Scotland. The

Read More »

Help keep our work going

We rely on donations from people like you to keep fighting for equality for people with ME.

Donate

Get actions alerts and news direct to your inbox

You can choose what you want to be kept up to date on.

Subscribe
Scroll to Top