Tuller: PACE authors “wrapping themselves in victimhood”

Journalist and public health expert Dr. David Tuller has, on Virology Blog, attacked a recent commentary in Nature that included “hard-line opponents” of research into chronic fatigue syndrome with climate change denialists and pro-tobacco campaigners who engage in “endless information requests, complaints to researchers’ universities, online harassment, distortion of scientific findings and even threats of violence.”
Both Dr. Tuller and Professor James Coyne have interpreted this conflation as what Tuller describes as “a reference to the angry response of patients and advocates to the indefensible claims made by the PACE trial.”
The Nature commentary, Dr. Tuller said, showed the extent to which the idea that the PACE authors have been subjected to threats and unfair campaigning “has been accepted as fact by the UK medical and academic establishment.” He described the PACE authors as “wrapping themselves in victimhood,” which had served as “a tactic that has shielded their work from legitimate and much-needed scrutiny.”
Both Dr. Tuller and Professor Coyne note, in their articles, the role of the Science Media Centre in introducing the theme of “harassment” to British media reports on PACE.
Dr. Tuller said, “Patients and advocates have raised… legitimate concerns, in every possible academic, scientific and popular forum. This effort has been framed by the investigators, The Lancet and the Science Media Centre as a vicious and anti-scientific “campaign” against PACE.”
But, he said, “The reality is that patients have been protesting a study they know to be deeply flawed. Sometimes they have protested very, very loudly. That’s what people do when they are desperate for help, and no one is listening. To call it harassment is disgraceful.”

Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp
Email

Latest News

Image is a sky blue rectangle, with an image of the #MEAction Maryland's logo that has the words Maryland State Chapter over an image of a lighthouse. On the righthand side if the image are the words, Join #MEAction's Marylans's #HelpMESenator Campaign in black font.

Join #MEAction Maryland’s #HelpMESenator Campaign

We are writing this article to share some exciting news! On Tuesday, September 26, ME advocates delivered copies of the book, The Puzzle Solver, by Tracie White with Ronald W. Davis, PhD, along with information about ME and Long Covid to Senators on the Hill. The books were donated by an individual living with severe ME/CFS in an effort to raise

Read More »
a collection of millionsmisisng pictures featuring people protesting over the years in red shirts and with protest signs. white dashses connect the photos. the words words "the Story of the #MillionsMissing" is in white font in the top lefthand corner with the #MEAction logo there. The words "Coming Soon" is handwriting font is in the top righthand corner.

“#MillionsMissing is our drumbeat”–Preview Party 9/24

RSVP TODAY: We are hosting a preview party for the new, virtual Home of the #MillionsMissing this Sunday, September 24th, at 12 pm PT/ 3 pm ET/ 8 pm BST! RSVP & Get Zoom Link Here We have always had to be creative in telling Our Story – the story of M.E. – to the world

Read More »

JNNP to publish edited rapid response by MEAction UK.

MEAction UK have been in communication with the BMJ and are delighted to announce that the Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery & Psychiatry (JNNP) are publishing an edited version of our rapid response to  ‘Anomalies in the review process and interpretation of the evidence in the NICE guideline for chronic fatigue syndrome and myalgic encephalomyelitis’. We

Read More »