PLOS One posts "notification" of intent to evaluate James Coyne's PACE data request

PLOS One today published a statement that its staff were evaluating Professor James Coyne’s request for data from a PACE trial paper published in the journal in 2012. Professor Coyne said on social media that the move “represents progress”.
King’s College London had denied Professor Coyne’s request on behalf of the study authors and had treated it as a Freedom of Information Act request, even though Coyne had explicitly made it with reference to PLOS One’s data-sharing policy.
PLOS One’s statement appears online in the comments section of the paper and notes that the version of their policy that applied when the article was published requires authors “to make freely available any materials and information described in their publication that may be reasonably requested by others for the purpose of academic, non-commercial research” and “also notes that access to the data should not compromise confidentiality in the context of human-subject research.”
They further stated that “PLOS staff are following up on the different concerns raised about this article as per our internal processes. As part of our follow up we are seeking further expert advice on the analyses reported in the article, and we will evaluate how the request for the data from this study relates to the policy that applies to the publication. These evaluations will inform our next steps as we look to address the concerns that have been noted.”
Professor Coyne, in a brief blog post, said “I do think there will be some resolution, but it will take until after the holidays.”
King’s College’s letter of refusal to Professor Coyne described his data request as “vexatious”, and as having “improper motive” and a “polemical” purpose. The refusal was met with swift condemnation from leading figures in science, including Professor Chris Chambers of Cardiff University, who said, “If @KingsCollegeLon is seeking to do itself ‘reputational damage’, hiding trial data shd do the job.”
Dr Richard Smith, the former editor of the BMJ, said on Twitter: “King’s College is surely making a mistake in holding back data from a controversial trial” and today published a lengthy BMJ blog post titled, “QMUL and King’s college should release data from the PACE trial”.
Influential blog Retraction Watch reported on PLOS One’s notification notice and quoted lead PACE author Professor Peter White as saying, “We understand PLOS One are following up concerns expressed about the article, according to their internal processes. We will be happy to work with them to address any queries they might have regarding the research.”
The PACE trial was a controversial £5 million randomized trial whose authors claim it showed that cognitive behavioral therapy and graded exercise therapy were effective treatments for some patients with chronic fatigue syndrome.​

Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp
Email

1 thought on “PLOS One posts "notification" of intent to evaluate James Coyne's PACE data request”

Comments are closed.

Latest News

rectangle image with a greyish background. three white pillows stacked from smallest to largest. the words, Pillow Writers en Español in black font. the #MEAction logo in the bottom right corner.

Pillow Writers en Español

#MEAction is thrilled to announce Pillow Writers Network has expanded once again! This time with a dedicated group for Spanish speakers: Join us for our Pillow Writers En Español meetings! A place where ME/CFS/Long Covid patients are welcome to participate through writing. This #MEAction-sponsored event has been held in English for over three years. We

Read More »

Happy Juneteenth + Black Disabled Authors Reading List

Happy Juneteenth from all of us here at #MEAction! Juneteenth commemorates June 19th, 1865 when slavery of African-Americans was officially enforced. To celebrate we have put together a summer reading list of books by disabled Black authors. Keah Brown is an American author who was born with cerebral palsy. She created the popular hashtag #disabledandcute

Read More »
white rectangle with red splashes of tiny red dots in all four corners. #MEAction logo at the top. #MEAction Minnesota Helps Save Long Covid Program in red font.

Minnesota’s Long COVID Funding Saved from Elimination

We have good news! The first-in-the-nation Long COVID program run by the Minnesota Department of Health (MDH) has been saved from elimination! This means #MEAction will be able to continue its work helping Minnesotans with ME/CFS, Long COVID and related conditions access vital home and community-based support services, as part of our multi-year grant.   Last

Read More »
Scroll to Top