'Unrest' at the Scottish Parliament

The Time for Unrest event at the Scottish Parliament on 30th January was an opportunity to raise awareness of Myalgic Encephalomyelitis (ME) among Members of the Scottish Parliament (MSPs), and ask them to take action to support the 21,000 people with ME in Scotland. Attended by over 70 people, it attracted an unprecedented number of MSPs and was described as “one of the most popular events I have seen” by the event manager at the Scottish Parliament.
The evening reception brought MSPs together to meet people with ME, charity representatives, and key ME advocates from across Scotland. Hosted by Ben Macpherson, MSP, the event highlighted the need for better understanding of ME amongst health professionals, fair access to welfare benefits, and properly funded collaborative research.
The event was so well attended it was standing room only. Photo by Anneleen Lindsay
Jennifer Brea, director of the documentary Unrest, joined the evening via Skype, introduced a clip from the film and joined the discussion following it. Her opening words were incredibly profound and cut to the heart of the issue: “The debate over whether this illness is physiological is over. But despite this – and this is true in Scotland, it’s true across the UK, it’s true all around the world – we’ve done almost nothing to invest in the research and care of this patient population due to the stigma, the misperceptions and the invisibility of the disease.”
A 20-minute excerpt from the film was shown, powerfully illustrating the severely debilitating nature of ME and the issues that sufferers face. The author Nasim Marie Jafry, parent Lorraine Butter and Edinburgh University’s Professor Chris Ponting were some of the speakers who emphasised the urgent need for better understanding among medical professionals, better provision of care for patients, and the dire lack of properly funded collaborative research. Powerful stories were told during the discussion and MSP’s heard first-hand examples of the injustices and neglect suffered by so many present. This was contrasted with anticipation and hope; a feeling among attendees that such a gathering could make a difference. As Gillian Grant of the Glasgow ME support group said, “Unrest is creating a feeling that change is finally coming and the buzz in the room that evening certainly matched that”.
MSP John Mason meets Emma Shorter, a prominent Scottish ME activist. Photo by Anneleen Lindsay
The aim of the event was simple: raising awareness of ME and getting MSPs to take action in two ways – asking their local Health Board to fund a specialist nurse for people with ME, and asking NHS Education for Scotland about the education and training it currently delivers on ME. Follow-up activities include a petition to Parliament calling for funding for research and education for healthcare professionals, as well as continuing the campaign for specialist support in Scotland.
The widespread media interest in the event ensured even further awareness raising around the UK. There was excellent coverage of the event in Scotland, with articles in both major Scottish national newspapers and in many local papers. Coverage elsewhere in the UK included articles in the Daily Mail and various local papers

Background to the Event

Who attended? 
The Parliamentary event was organised by Janet Sylvester and Kim Gurav, with a group of a dozen volunteers affiliated with #MEAction. It was hosted by Ben Macpherson, MSP for Edinburgh Northern and Leith, who got involved after attending last year’s #MillionsMissing protest at the Scottish Parliament.
Also at the event were representatives from six regional support groups from across Scotland: Aberdeen, the Borders, Cumbernauld, Dumfries and Galloway, Fife and Glasgow. The three major ME charities in Scotland all attended: the ME Association, Action for ME and ME Research UK. There were 15 MSPs present with cross-party representation: this was an unusually high turn-out for a volunteer organised and funded event.  The high attendance of MSPs was –  as a number of them commented – as a result of receiving dozens of emails from constituents urging them to go along. 
Some of the MSPs who attended. Photo by Anneleen Lindsay
What happened at the event?
The event opened with a short Skype introduction from Jennifer Brea, director of Unrest, and was followed by a 20-minute clip from the film which included footage of Jen’s own struggles as well as some of Jessica Bearman Taylor’s story; a young woman from the UK.
Nasim Marie Jafry was then introduced and she discussed the political reframing of the illness from ME (treated as a neurological illness) to CFS (treated as a psychosomatic condition), and the difference between her treatment in the 80’s and early 90’s. She spoke of how it appears that medical treatment has gone backwards for this disease.
The issues with Graded Exercise Therapy (GET) were highlighted by Lorraine Butter, who has ME and is a mother of three children with ME.She described how forced GET had harmed one son in particular. This was a shocking story and her anguish could be felt throughout the room. Professor Chris Ponting from Edinburgh University then spoke of the need for significant investment in joined-up, multi-disciplinary research if there were to be any possibility of making good progress.
During the Q&A session the stories of injustice and neglect came out again and again. Louise McAllan from Stirling commented, “It was moving to be there as patients’ and carers’ voices were heard for the first time, and to feel heard myself for the first time. Those in the room unfamiliar with the disease were visibly struck by the level of suffering experienced by patients.”
It was particularly powerful having a number of people present share their own experiences as it brought the difficulties patients face back to Scotland, impressing that change is needed here. An underlying theme of patient’s experiences was the complete lack of care and poor treatment many had received. One patient spoke about how he had been refused benefits unless he took part in a programme of CBT/GET. His experience left many in the room shocked and several in tears, including Jen on Skype, impressing on MSPs the seriousness of the situation. In response to further questions the panel spoke of the need for education of healthcare professionals in order for them to better understand ME, and stressed the urgent need for more specialist nursing services like that in Fife – the only such service in Scotland.
What next?
The seriousness of the situation clearly hit home to the MSPs present from the discussions and comments they made afterwards. Fulton MacGregor, MSP, tweeted later about the very moving contributions of speakers and of “a strong take home message for the MSPs there!”
During a conversation at the event, John Mason, MSP, showed concern and sympathy for people with ME applying for benefits and the huge stress this put them under. He spoke of looking into the process and finding out more about his constituents with ME.
On Twitter Claire Baker, MSP, described the evening as an important meeting “highlighting what it is like to live with ME and campaigning for more understanding and research”. These reactions show that when people are presented with the shocking facts and the lived experience of people with ME, they realise that action needs to be taken. The challenge is making more people fully aware of this, and ensuring action is actually taken.
The follow-up activities will be:

  • A campaign to encourage people to email their MSPs, especially those who did not attend asking them to contact their local Health Board and NHS Education Scotland.
  • Sending a ‘Guide to ME in Scotland,’ a briefing paper prepared by Emma Shorter, to all MSPs.
  • Continuing to work on more media coverage in Scotland for the campaign.
  • Launching a Scottish petition.

An additional outcome of the event was bringing together people from across Scotland who are active in working for change for people with ME. It was the first time a group like this has gathered in Scotland, and it increased awareness for everyone of the breadth and number of people involved. The publicised request to email MSPs also galvanised the ME community in considerable numbers, making them especially aware of their strong contribution in lobbying for change.
The event organisers want to thank all the volunteers who helped make the evening such a success – a huger number of people across Scotland got involved with the campaign by emailing their MSPs, sharing on social media, writing press releases and contacting their local newspapers.
Volunteers Janet Sylvester and Kim Gurav, the main organisers of the event said:
“A huge thanks to all the volunteers who helped make the Parliamentary event such a success. The event succeeded in raising awareness of MSPs of the huge impact that ME has in Scotland and we hope that we can capitalise on this success and make sure that the momentum is not lost.”
The volunteers who made it happen (those well enough to attend). Photo by Anneleen Lindsay
MSPs who attended

Claire Baker Member for Mid Scotland and Fife Labour
Claudia Beamish Member for South Scotland Labour
Alexander Burnett Member for Aberdeenshire West Conservative
Kate Forbes Member for Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch SNP
Emma Harper Member for South Scotland SNP
Alison Johnstone Member for Lothian Green Party
Gordon Lindhurst Member for Lothian Conservative
Lewis MacDonald Member for North East Scotland Labour
Fulton Macgregor Member for Coatbridge and Chryston SNP
Ben Macpherson Member for Edinburgh Northern and Leith SNP
Gillian Martin Member for Aberdeenshire East SNP
John Mason Member for Glasgow Shettleston SNP
Joan McApline Member for South Scotland SNP
Colin Smyth Member for South Scotland Labour
Annie Wells Member for Glasgow Conservative



6 thoughts on “'Unrest' at the Scottish Parliament”

  1. So good to see this happening. Skype, internet are so useful to those with ME who can manage to use them. My first diagnosis 35 years ago in NZ was by a scottish doctor who said ‘ I can see you are ill, but we dont know what this is.’ Things have gone backward since then, and now they are starting to go forward finally. Well done Jennifer Brea. I have some ideas for the sequel….

  2. “Specialist nursing services in Fife” ! ! !
    Oh really. ? ? ? Is that meant to be some kind of joke ?
    I live in Fife. I’ve had ME for 39 years. There is no service for people with M.E. in Fife.

  3. Fantastic, so well done to you all! Powerful movement will come from being seen, heard and acknowledged.
    Wonderful that you found a format that worked for the politician’s schedules. Very much hoping we can do the same here in Australia.
    Congratulations, may your outcomes be realised and compassion upheld. Solidarity!

  4. Raquel mena taylor

    Enhorabuena al equipo organizador de este evento en el parlamento de Escocia. Estoy entusiasmada !!!! Podríamos ver el vídeo de 20 minutos que se mostró, sobre la película Unrest???, Sería muy interesante para los que hacemos eventos familiares y de amigos, para concienciar sobre la enfermedad.
    Muchas gracias !!!

Comments are closed.

Latest News

A rectangle image with a blueish/purple background. The words, "A Year of Exciting Medical Education Achievements" is in white font on the left hand side with the #MEAction logo underneath. On the righthand side is an image of Jaime Seltzer with a step and repeat and poster at the SDMI conference.

A Year of Exciting Medical Education Achievements

A year ago, we were proud to announce that #MEAction and Mayo Clinic Rochester had won a grant for diagnostic improvement, with Ravindra Ganesh, and Stephanie Grach, and I on the grant as co-investigators. Our project, Improving Diagnostic Accuracy of Myalgic Encephalomyelitis/Chronic Fatigue Syndrome Through Implementation of an Enhanced Education Protocol and Care Process Model

Read More »
a light orange rectangle with a burnt orange outline. in the box, there are orange flag garlands hanging in both top corners with orange confetti in the middle and at the top. in the bottom corners fall leaves. in the middle of the box the word, "OUR BOLDEST THANKS" in burnt orange. the #MEAction logo at the bottom.

#MEAction Shares Our Thanks for Your BOLD ACTIONS

During this time of thankfulness and gratitude, #MEAction staff wants to share what BOLD ACTIONS we are thankful our volunteers and community have taken throughout the year. We thought we could reflect together on all that we have accomplished this year and how every single one of us is important in this powerful community. A

Read More »
red rectangle. on the left side of the rectangle an image of a desktop computer that features the mepedia home page. the words "Live Now!" are stacked four times and fall behind the desktop image. on the right side of the rectangle, the words " check out the updated, expanded, and revamped mepedia! then there is the #mepedia logo with the words a project of #MEAction at the bottom.

Check out the Updated, Expanded, Revamped MEpedia!

Great news! About six months ago, we began a project to update, expand, and revamp MEpedia. Due to a generous grant, we were able to create a project scope, hire respected experts in accessibility and MediaWiki development, and make several important changes to MEpedia! Visit the New MEpedia MEpedia is a vital resource MEpedia is one of the most utilized resources for researchers,

Read More »